The Government has launched its long-awaited consultation into ‘off-payroll working’ (IR35) in the private sector.
In April 2017, the IR35 rules were amended for public sector engagements, for the first time making engagers responsible for assessing the IR35 status of limited company contractors.
Despite bountiful evidence to suggest the public sector changes have been chaotic, and HMRC’s IR35 assessment tools inaccurate, the Government appears to be convinced that a further extension to the private sector is a good idea.
Indeed, according to today’s publication, the implementation of ‘off payroll’ rules in the public sector has resulted in a “£410m” windfall for the Treasury.
Justifying this new consultation, the document suggests that “the taxpayer could be missing up to £1.2bn a year by 2023 as a result of people getting the rules wrong, and incorrectly paying tax as if they were self-employed.”
Interestingly, according to the factsheet which forms part of the consultation pack, the Government estimates that “…two thirds of people working through a company are genuinely self-employed and not affected by these rules. But around one third are working like employees.”
But then, the introduction to the consultation document states: “It is estimated that in 90% of cases within the private sector, the IR35 rules are not applied correctly.”
What are the prospects for a private sector extension?
The consultation document makes it clear than HMRC isn’t simply considering an extension of the current public sector IR35 reforms, but also alternatives, such as supply chain assurances / checks, and additional record-keeping processes by clients.
In theory, private sector changes could be implemented as soon as April 2019.
Hopefully, the strength of feeling from within industry in general will be made very clear during the consultation process, and sense will prevail – as a rollout to the private sector will be massively more impactful that this last April’s public sector changes.
Further Information / Downloads
- The consultation will last until 11:45pm on August 10th 2018, with a Government response to feedback due later in the year.
- Interested parties are also directed to read a 58 page independent research report into the implementation of the April 2017 public sector IR35 reforms.
- You can read the consultation document here.
- You can also download independent research into the impact of the April 2017 public sector off-payroll reforms.
- If you would like to submit your response to the consultation, you can do so via email or post.